Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <[email protected]>
17 KiB
Slowdown audit, November 2026
A sweep of main (c02ede3bb, 13 November 2026) for bugs that freeze the page
or hold the frame rate down. This page lists what was found, why it happens and
how to fix it, and names the pull request that carries each fix.
PERFORMANCE.md is the measured baseline of a healthy build; this page is the list of things that fall outside it.
How it was measured
- Keyless dev server, headless Chrome at 1440 x 900 on Apple silicon (Metal through ANGLE), default globe map.
- Per scenario: load, a spell at rest, scripted drags and wheel zooms, then a
settle. Long tasks were counted with a
PerformanceObserver, the hot function named from a CPU profile, andglobe.getHeight,scene.sampleHeight,scene.pickand friends wrapped to count calls and time. - A long task is one main-thread task over 50 ms. With no layers on, the baseline is two at load (longest about 240 ms) and none afterwards, with zero frames rendered while the camera is still.
- Four profiling sessions ran on one machine at the same time, so absolute timings carry some noise. Ratios against the baseline are what to read.
Nothing here was measured on Google Photorealistic 3D Tiles, on a discrete or integrated PC GPU, or with keyed feeds (AISStream, FIRMS, TomTom). Those rows are marked "read in code".
Findings and fixes
Worst first. "Fix" names the pull request that carries the fix.
Measured
| # | Where | What happens | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bike Share, local data layers, Transit, Rail | 18 s freeze switching Bike Share on over New York (2,519 stations); 2.7 s on Data Centers; multi-second freezes with Transit while zooming | #1688, #1689 |
| 2 | Shipwrecks | 3 to 5 s freeze when the markers are built over loaded terrain; a share link with the layer on held the loading screen for 22.9 s in one run | #1703 |
| 3 | Camera | Rendering stops until reload: at a whole-globe view looking straight down, pan a few times, then scroll one notch | #1704 |
| 4 | Street Traffic | Zooming at 250 m over Manhattan: 25 long tasks in 24 s, longest 746 ms, 6.6 s in total | #1705 |
| 5 | ALPR cameras | Depth samples inside the overlay paint, repeated on every re-enable: 240 samples and about 1 s across eight toggles. A first-sample freeze of up to 1.9 s was seen in the sweep but not on a second day | #1706 |
| 6 | Wind | First zoom after load: up to 14 long tasks (longest 414 ms). Re-measured as one-off shader links, not a standing cost: see below | none proposed |
| 7 | Submarine cables | About 2 s of long tasks on load, heap briefly at 1 GB, about 0.5 s again on each re-enable | #1707 (first step), #1722 (batched primitives) |
| 8 | Live Flights at whole-globe view with detection labels | Fine on the test machine; at 4x CPU throttle, 8 fps with 143 long tasks in 15 s | #1708 (fleet pass), #1719 (overlay) |
| 9 | Radio | 7 to 10 long tasks when the directory loads, longest 447 ms | #1709 |
| 10 | Pointer pick | Not reproduced on a second look: see below | none needed |
| 11 | CCTV | A still-image camera holds continuous rendering at 60 frames a second although its picture changes about every 10 s | #1710 |
Read in code
| # | Where | What happens | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | /api/firms |
The whole fire set is filtered, serialised and sent uncompressed on every request; 15 to 55 MB estimated in a heavy season | #1711 |
| 13 | AIS store | Both vessel maps are walked on every position message, and sorted whole once past the cap | #1712 |
| 14 | Satellite clouds on the 3D Tiles map | A CPU pass over a 4096 x 2048 image, 90 to 180 ms measured on a synthetic canvas, twice in a row | #1713 (canvas path), #1721 (shader) |
| 15 | NVG and FLIR styles | Over 100 texture reads per pixel, and 60 renders a second while the style is on. Measured afterwards: the reads cost 0.4 ms a frame at 1440 x 900 and 1.2 ms at 2560 x 1440 | #1718 |
| 16 | Wind server | Full 0.25 degree GRIB fields decoded on the event loop. Measured afterwards: 68 ms blocked per warm refresh, about 250 ms on the first, about 400 ms when all six keys refresh together | #1717 |
| 17 | Imported geo files and other per-feature ground clamps | Measured afterwards: imported files do not freeze; see below | none needed |
Cause and fix, per finding
1. Terrain height reads
globe.getHeight casts a ray against the mesh of the tile under the point, and
scene.sampleHeight renders a depth pass. Transit asked for every trail fix of
every vehicle several times per poll; Bike Share sampled every station in one
go. The fix keeps heights per point in one shared reader with a read budget
(src/services/terrainSurface.js) and spreads the depth samples across frames.
2. Shipwrecks
rebuild() in src/layers/shipwrecks/index.js adds 7,958 billboards with
heightReference: CLAMP_TO_GROUND. Each constructor runs
Billboard._updateClamping, which intersects a ray with the terrain mesh,
synchronously: 4.8 of the 4.9 s. The cost is only paid when terrain is loaded
at the time the markers are built, so a cold start with the layer in the URL
sometimes escapes it.
Fix: do not clamp. Wrecks are at sea and the markers already ignore the depth
test, so place them on the ellipsoid with HeightReference.NONE.
3. Camera: rendering stops after pan then zoom
Pure Cesium; no application code is involved. Above 1,000 km,
ScreenSpaceCameraController handleZoom rotates the camera about the cross
product of the picked point's normal and the screen centre's normal whenever
their dot product is between 0 and 1. With the pointer on the exact centre pixel
the two are the same vector, yet n · n often rounds to 0.9999999999999999,
so the check passes with a zero axis. Camera.rotate then throws
DeveloperError: normalized result is not a number from
Scene.initializeFrame, outside the scene's own try/catch, so
scene.renderError never fires and Cesium stops its render loop for good. The
pans in the first reproduction only moved the camera to a pose where the
rounding goes that way.
Fix: make camera.rotate ignore a zero or non-finite axis, and recover from any
stopped loop by restoring the last drawn camera pose and restarting it a bounded
number of times before showing Cesium's error panel.
4. Street Traffic road loading
Three costs in one task after the detail tiles arrive, in
src/layers/traffic/source.js:
outsideDetailTilesclips every coarse z12 road against every loaded detail tile (up to 16) for four regions.- The composed set is then handed on with
replace: true, soingestion.jsparses every road again although each tile was parsed as it streamed. parseRoads(model.js) askscachedGroundFlooronce per coordinate, and each call builds several string keys.
Fix: clip once per coarse tile against the detail tiles' union box and slice the work across frames (or do it in the vector-tile worker); reuse the roads parsed while streaming and parse only the clipped coarse remainder; look the floor up once per floor cell within a parse.
This is separate from the one-viewport-tile-at-a-time loading recorded in KNOWN-ISSUES.md.
5. ALPR cameras
refineAnchors and anchorFor in src/layers/alpr/overlay.js call
scene.sampleHeight from the overlay's paint, four per paint. Each is a depth
render and a readPixels; the first one also compiles the pick shader. Results
are kept on the entity, so a rebuild or a re-enable samples everything again.
Fix: on a terrain globe read globe.getHeight through the shared terrain reader
instead of sampling; keep the answers in a map keyed by camera that outlives the
entities; move what sampling remains out of the paint into a queue of one per
frame.
6. Wind
The first reading blamed the layer's 916,476 vertices for slow depth reads during zoom. Measuring again did not support that: depth reads cost the same with and without Wind, hiding every wind primitive left pick time unchanged, and the stalls appear on the first zoom only, as shader programs link (seven programs, about 0.5 s, long tasks up to 166 ms). Later zooms had none.
The roughly 30 renders a second are the animation itself. It is already capped
at 30 Hz and stops when paused, hidden, out of view or under reduced motion;
lowering the rate would change how the layer looks. disable() releases the
baked geometry on purpose, at the price of one task of about 130 ms on
re-enable.
A third look, timing every program link on a preview build, settled it: Wind owns two shader programs, both link during load in 9 to 18 ms, and none ever linked during a zoom. The programs that do link on a zoom are Cesium's own globe-surface variants, with Wind on or off, and Cesium links them synchronously. No fix is proposed.
7. Submarine cables
src/layers/submarineCables/ingestion.js loads both collections through
Cesium.GeoJsonDataSource with clampToGround. Switching the layer on is one
task of about 1.4 s, and 1.2 s of it is Cesium reading the terrain height for
the 1,917 ground-clamped landing markers, all created in the first frame,
including the ones behind the globe.
Fix, first step: start the landing markers hidden and let the existing horizon sweep show the visible ones a few dozen per frame.
Fix, second step: draw from batched primitives in place of the entity data sources: one ground polyline primitive for the lines, one billboard collection for the landing markers, one point collection and one static polyline primitive for the reference stems, all kept while the layer is off. That removes the visualiser tasks, the stall on switch-off and on re-enable, and about 900 MB of heap. The first switch-on still links shaders and builds the ground-line geometry once.
8. Live Flights at whole-globe view
Two costs that scale with the 7,500 aircraft of a full poll:
- The fleet pass (
src/layers/flights/rendering.js, every 80 ms) dead-reckons each visible aircraft and askscachedGroundFloorfor it, including aircraft at cruise altitude that can never touch the floor. Each lookup formats numbers to strings several times and rewrites a cache entry: 40% of the busy time. - The detection overlay (
src/data/detection.js_drawOverlay) collects every detectable object and strokes every bracket on every frame.
Fix for the first: skip the floor path for a contact clearly above any terrain, make the floor-cell key a number, and stop promoting the cache entry on every read.
The second turned out smaller than it looked. The bracket strokes are already
one path per colour, and collecting the objects is about 3 ms of a 56 ms frame
at 4x throttle once the first fix is in. What costs is the per-object loop in
_drawOverlay (projection, occlusion, alpha, twelve path calls per bracket).
Fix for the second: keep what a sweep built and reuse it on the next paint when the view and every contact are exactly what it was built from, compared value by value so no layer has to announce a change. Between two fleet passes most paints qualify, which cuts frame work by a fifth to a third on a still camera at full speed. At 4x throttle a frame outlasts a fleet pass, no paint qualifies, and the gain is a few milliseconds; the fleet pass is what dominates there.
9. Radio
stationTags() in src/layers/radio/categories.js splits and normalises a
station's tags on every hasTag call, and buildRadioCategories runs that for
every station against every category, twice.
Fix: normalise once per station at ingest and count categories from that.
10. Pointer pick
Three sessions saw a single scene.pick of 207 to 342 ms during a gesture and
attributed it to pickPointer in src/voice/pointerPick.js. Timing every pick
across pointer rests, drags and wheel bursts did not bear that out: of 78 picks
with CCTV on over London all but two took 3 to 8 ms, and with five heavy layers
on, 81 picks took 5 to 30 ms apart from the first (135 ms). pickPointer picks
at most once per pointer rest.
The slow pick is the first pick after a layer appears, once per page load, most
likely the pick shader compiling, and its stack is CCTV's own hover pick
(src/layers/cctv/hover.js). No fix is proposed: removing the dwell pick would
only move the one-off cost to the next click.
11. CCTV still-image cameras
src/layers/cctv/projection.js holds continuous rendering for as long as any
projected camera is active and redraws the projection every frame.
Fix: hold only for video. For a still image, request one render when a new image lands or while a focus fade runs.
12. /api/firms
server/providers/firms.js builds the payload and calls JSON.stringify per
request, with no kept body and no compression, and the client refetches every
ten minutes.
Fix: keep the response bytes and their gzip and serve those, as the OpenSky provider does. The route filters to the trailing 24 hours at serve time, so the bytes can only be reused while that filter keeps the same records (about a minute at a time): bursts and several clients gain most, and every response is about seven times smaller.
13. AIS store
server/providers/vessels/ais-store.js calls pruneAisStreamCache() for every
message; the static-data map is never pruned.
Fix: prune on a timer, evict in insertion order, and drop a vessel's static entry with the vessel.
14. Satellite clouds on the 3D Tiles map
src/layers/weather/infraredImage.js runs getImageData, a per-pixel power
curve and putImageData over the whole canvas.
Fix: a 256-entry lookup table applied in place for the canvas path, which halves it; then, for the shell on the 3D Tiles map, the same curve in its fragment shader from a strength uniform, so the image is never read back and a strength change builds no new image.
15. NVG and FLIR styles
src/styles/surveillance.js loops 11 x 11 texture reads per pixel and
src/styles/thermal.js totals 106. Timed on the GPU, those loops cost about
0.4 ms a frame at 1440 x 900 and 1.2 ms at 2560 x 1440 on the test machine:
real, but small there. The standing cost is that a style with animated grain
holds continuous rendering at 60 frames a second.
Fix: split the bloom into a row pass and a column pass, which gives the same picture from a fifth to a half of the reads, and step the grain's clock at 15 Hz, asking for one frame per step instead of holding the render loop. The grain then changes 15 times a second, which is visible in motion.
Switching on any style stage at all costs more than the bloom did (1.8 ms a frame at 1440 x 900 for the one-line noir style). That was not looked into.
16. Wind server
server/providers/wind/decode.js decodes about a million doubles per message
synchronously, hourly, for six keys.
Fix: decode on a worker thread, and keep the sampled U and V of the last forecast file per model so that choosing an overlay fetches only its field.
17. Per-feature ground clamps
heightReference: CLAMP_TO_GROUND per feature is also set in
installations/rendering.js, alpr/presentation.js, ghostMaps/index.js,
earthquakes/index.js, airQuality/index.js, news/index.js and
osmPlaces/index.js. Their counts were small in these runs (30 to 1,500) and
none froze.
Imported geo files were the one unbounded case, and measuring them cleared
them: 20,000 generated points (the import cap) finish in about 1.5 s with a
longest task near 0.5 s, because settleGroundPins in
src/data/geoFileImport.js already places pins with HeightReference.NONE and
resolves heights 256 at a time with a yield between batches. No fix is needed.
Checked and fine
- Start-up of a production build: viewer ready in about 0.5 s, loading screen gone at 1.6 s, three long tasks totalling about 300 ms.
- Idle: no frames rendered with no layers on; every render hold was released when its layer went off.
- Leaks: all 41 layers toggled three times and ten of them eight times; no timer, scene listener, primitive or data source grew per cycle. The heap levelled off near 320 MB over 7.5 minutes of toggling eleven layers.
- At most one long task after load: Military, Satellites (including 11,903 Starlink points), Earthquakes, News, Wildlife, GNSS, Drone Airspace, Military Installations, Fire Perimeters, rain radar, lightning, and satellite clouds on the globe map.
- Live Flights at city scale with the same 7,500 aircraft loaded: 60 fps, no long tasks.
Not covered
- Google Photorealistic 3D Tiles: nothing was run there. Depth sampling is the only height source on that map, so findings 4, 5 and 17 may be worse.
- Live Vessels, FIRMS with data, TomTom traffic, Local ADS-B.
- Frame rate on anything but one Apple silicon machine.
- One all-layers run over Manhattan grew the heap from 346 to 638 MB in 60 s; whether that is retained was not established.
- One Satellites load showed a 5.2 s long task once and never again in four more loads.