Commit Graph
1233 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Manjunath PaparajuandSameh Khamis d68adcea21 Remove the Cyber HUD layout and keep its sonar as a visual style
Display > HUD > Sonar now turns the sonar sweep on over Tactical or
Minimal. It is off by default, ON reveals its five sliders, and it keeps
its guards: an OFF control, the sweep only while the HUD is visible and
outside Cockpit, no animation under reduced motion, and repaint timers
re-armed only after a drawn frame that still shows contacts.

The Cyber layout, its shell skin and its Cockpit lanes are removed. Share
links, scenes, saved views and set_hud that name Cyber open Tactical with
Sonar on; links and scene shots record Tactical with Sonar under the same
code, and a restored state that names another layout turns Sonar off.
set_cyber_sonar keeps its name and works under any layout. A newer Sonar
toggle or voice setting wins over a share-link restore that lands later.

From 1200px wide the command dock and World Timeline sit 74px above the
bottom edge, as in the Omnibar layout, leaving the bottom row to the map
attribution (left) and the Power Up corner row (right). The attribution
moves to the bottom right when the page runs right to left, where the
corner row sits at the bottom left, and a long credit line wraps upward
before reaching the corner row. The Tactical bottom-right readout sits
8px above Power Up and the coordinates start level with it. The World
Timeline is narrowed to sit between the corners. Toasts keep clear of
the raised dock and the chat and voice panel height budgets subtract its
rise. Below 1200px the layout is unchanged. The left rail treats the
centered World Timeline and voice control as obstacles only where they
reach a laid-out panel.

On top of the Omnibar: sonar.css replaces cyber.css after the Omnibar
imports, the Omnibar's HUD guide step now says Layout picks Tactical or
Minimal, and the Omnibar's Tactical bottom-right readout keeps the same
8px above Power Up.

Co-authored-by: Sameh Khamis <[email protected]>
2026-11-18 15:47:27 -08:00
German Khokhlov 81fe7f88cc fix(cctv): settle the review of the count markers
Bugs:
- Cameras on one mount stay side by side after their geometry is built,
  so a click or a settled view no longer folds them back into one icon.
- A count click yields to a card drawn over the marker and to another
  layer's object under it, waits while the cockpit or tracking holds the
  view, and flies at most halfway, so a long chain of cameras still splits.
- The active camera's icon is never covered by a count, transparent
  corners of the marker no longer catch clicks, and a count hidden under
  the HUD keeps its lone cameras.
- A lone camera joins only its nearest count and never bridges two; cameras
  close enough to draw as icons take part too, at their drawn icon size.
- Groups across the antimeridian keep their longitude; the flight frames
  the highest mount; markers on ground below the ellipsoid stay visible;
  counts fade outside the Scope circle.
- Mounts less than a metre apart count as one mount.
- A drawn-terrain height survives a late fallback answer, is read for an
  unresolved camera and for one projected off the window, is re-read when
  the terrain under it finishes loading or the terrain source changes, and
  the read budget no longer goes to the same misses each pass.

Cleanup: the glyph draws from one green SVG sprite instead of recolouring
pixels, marker-only constants move next to their use, layout tests check
behaviour rather than formulas, and docs and comments match the code.
docs/I18N.md names the one fixed notation of count badges as an exception.
2026-11-19 03:07:04 +04:00
Sameh Khamis d6972f8b78 An estimated aircraft position stands in on the trail only until the next received one (#1817)
* An estimated aircraft position stands in on the trail only until the next received one

* Changelog fragment for #1817
2026-11-18 14:05:39 -08:00
Sameh Khamis e19c84bae4 Make the fleet models, their handover and the vessel sprites a public entry point 2026-11-18 13:12:13 -08:00
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju 88919f760f Keep a lookup's places when one tile fails, and ship every tile as its own file
- A tile that cannot be read is left out of placesNear's answer instead of
  failing it; without the pack's index the cities are still the answer.
- The build no longer inlines the small tiles into one chunk that loaded
  with the first lookup: all 732 are their own files.
- A row at latitude 90 or longitude 180 is tiled where the lookups read it.
- --min-population 0 is taken as 0, not as the default.

Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-18 12:36:16 -08:00
Manjunath PaparajuandSameh Khamis 78305411eb Bundle smaller Wikidata settlements for nearby-place lookups
137,662 places of 1,000 to 14,999 people that Wikidata gives a population
and coordinates for, none already in the cities pack, in 732 tiles of
5 x 5 degrees with an index of row counts (CC0). Nothing loads with the
app: a lookup reads the index once and then only the tiles it touches.
placesNear lists the places around a point, and findPlace finds a small
place by name near the view when no city of that name is near. The cities
build script writes the tiles with --tiles; the step from rows to files is
checked offline.

Co-authored-by: Sameh Khamis <[email protected]>
2026-11-18 12:36:16 -08:00
German Khokhlov 2e18673df8 fix(cctv): stand cameras and count markers on the drawn terrain
When the terrain height batch loses a chunk to the rate limit, the cameras
in it keep a sea-level fallback height. In the mountains that put them far
under the surface, so the view pass judged them by a point that was not
where they are drawn: a tilted view dropped the count marker, a click on
the marker framed empty ground, and icons drifted on tilt and pan.

- A camera with no real ground height takes the height of the terrain the
  globe draws once it is near the screen (up to 300 reads a pass, through
  the height service), and a later answer from the batch replaces it.
- A count marker is anchored to the drawn terrain under its centre, and a
  click frames that ground.
- Cameras on one mount draw side by side, 30 px apart, each with its own
  callout, instead of as one icon with several callouts.

The photoreal map stack is not covered: terrain is not the surface there.
2026-11-19 00:03:34 +04:00
German Khokhlov 65942008bf fix(cctv): count a lone camera in the marker it sits against
A ground cell with one camera always drew its icon, so at some zooms a
camera poked out from under a count marker with its own callout.

An icon closer than the merge gap to a count marker now joins that marker:
the count grows by one and the icon, its callout and its card are not drawn.
Two lone cameras with no count beside them stay two icons, and the active
camera always keeps its own icon.
2026-11-18 21:23:41 +04:00
German Khokhlov c536d22ff0 feat(cctv): green count markers that grow with the count and carry a camera icon
A count marker now says what it counts and how much:

- Its height grows with the count, from 40 px for two cameras to 58 px for
  several thousand, with clear fill around the digits.
- A small single-camera map icon sits under the top of the ring and the
  number just below the centre, so the two never touch. The icon is built
  from the same sprite as a single camera on the map.
- Thousands print as 1.7K or 12K in every UI language.
- The camera layer is green: count markers and idle single cameras share
  the colour, the active camera stays gold and live-video cameras violet.
2026-11-18 20:48:33 +04:00
manjunath22466 7312280817 fix(earthquakes): address review follow-ups on click arbitration
A drifting touch tap or a cockpit-mode tap on a fire, quake or vessel card
beside an aircraft did nothing: the cards deferred to the aircraft, whose
click handler ignores such taps. Pick owners can now declare the clicks
they ignore (registerPickOwner(..., { declinesClick })); flights and
military decline a drag or a cockpit tap and CCTV declines any click that
is not clean, so a card over them keeps that tap.

Also from review:
- the selected quake's contour rings sit on the ground the disc is draped
  on, re-read through the heights service while they paint;
- a label's fly-to frames the whole disc for large quakes;
- a quake that ages out of the feed clears its selection as evicted;
- id-less quakes are named by their content, not their row;
- the Bhote Koshi trigger-record callout opens its source on a click, as
  its keyboard action does, and yields like the other cards;
- the card's place line is cut to 48 characters, its link hint shows only
  with an opener, and its accessible name carries depth, place and time; a
  link-less card's click and keyboard action fly to the quake;
- camera trace comparison scales its tolerance with the value and wraps
  heading and roll.
2026-11-18 19:19:41 +05:30
German Khokhlov e4e7b32289 refactor(i18n): show the installations status through translateStatusMessage 2026-11-18 16:52:52 +04:00
German Khokhlov dc13be07c0 docs(i18n): tighten the Mapped Installations status comments 2026-11-18 16:48:59 +04:00
German Khokhlov 93b091d082 Merge branch 'main' into fix/i18n-installations-note
# Conflicts:
#	scripts/package-boundaries.json
#	src/layers/installations/controls.js
2026-11-18 16:35:52 +04:00
German Khokhlov aabfa5e084 fix(cctv): paint count markers on the world overlay canvas
The scene renders at CSS resolution and is stretched on a high-density
display, so a count marker drawn as a scene sprite looked coarse next
to the camera callouts, which the world overlay paints at device
density.

Paint the markers through the overlay's custom paint lane instead, in
the callouts' typeface. Each paint reprojects the group centres; a
click is resolved against the rectangles painted in the last frame and
still zooms to the group without choosing a camera. A marker that would
cover HUD chrome is skipped, as overlay entries are.

With no aggregate sprites left, the contact sweep no longer needs to
skip them, so that exclusion is removed.
2026-11-18 15:31:20 +04:00
German Khokhlov 607796737c feat(cctv): show how many cameras a thinned marker stands for
Zoomed out, the layer keeps one camera per ground cell and drew it as an
ordinary icon, so nothing showed that dozens or hundreds of other cameras
sat behind it. A cell with two or more cameras is now one round marker
with the count inside, at the centre of its cameras. Single cameras and
the active camera keep their icons.

The count covers the whole cell, so it does not change while the cell
crosses the screen edge. Markers that would overlap on screen merge into
one carrying their sum. Counts above 999 use the compact form of the UI
language and widen the marker into a pill. Clicking a marker zooms to
its group and does not choose a camera.

Ambient cards and coverage attach only to cameras drawn as icons; the
camera picker keeps one representative per visible cell as before.
2026-11-18 14:26:37 +04:00
German Khokhlov e0437cfacb Merge branch 'main' into feat/australia-transit 2026-11-18 13:52:55 +04:00
Sameh Khamis c1ca67bdb1 feat(places): export normalizeOsrmSteps from sources/places so any route proxy serves Directions' turn-by-turn steps 2026-11-17 21:05:20 -08:00
Sameh Khamis ca5e82ae41 Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/main' into selection/no-tint
# Conflicts:
#	docs/CURRENT-STATE.md
2026-11-17 18:46:23 -08:00
Sameh Khamis dc9b1042df Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/main' into selection/no-tint 2026-11-17 17:53:51 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 4c0afcff9e Merge branch 'main' into fix/flights-feed-type 2026-11-17 17:52:37 -08:00
Sameh Khamis f49352d228 fix(selection): selecting or tracking a contact never recolours it
A tracked aircraft's icon and 3D model keep the colours they have
untracked in Flights and Military Flights (no cyan, no lighter amber);
only the icon's alpha changes (stale fade, clear while its model draws).
A selected vessel or aid keeps its type colour instead of white, and a
tracked satellite's dot keeps its class colour instead of yellow. An
emergency stays red while tracked.
2026-11-17 17:49:33 -08:00
Sameh Khamis f2537743ab fix(flights): class an aircraft by its feed's type from the first fix
A civil aircraft was drawn as an airliner until its type lookup answered,
even when its feed already named the type: a helicopter showed the
airliner icon and model for as long as the lookup took.

- Flights classes every contact, and picks its model, by the feed's own
  ICAO type designator from the first fix. A looked-up type replaces it
  once the lookup answers and outranks the feed's on every later poll;
  the lookup still runs and fills the type name and registration.
- A surface emitter category still keeps only a ground type (ZVEH, GRND)
  from the feed.
- State vectors have no type field, so an /api/flights answer may send
  `typeByIcao` beside them, by ICAO address, as `emergencyByIcao` is sent.
  The regional adsb.lol fallback now sends it from each row's `t`.
2026-11-17 17:37:48 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 914b28822a The followed aircraft's trail runs to where the aircraft is drawn
When an application places live contacts itself, the tracked trail was cut at the layer's own delayed clock, which can run minutes behind the placed aircraft: the trail ended far behind the aircraft, and its head was dropped while that clock warmed up. The trail now reads the aircraft's time off its own reports at the point where it is drawn, for Flights and Military Flights.
2026-11-17 17:36:36 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 39f2d0b165 Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/main' into fix/models-black
# Conflicts:
#	docs/CURRENT-STATE.md
2026-11-17 16:54:43 -08:00
Sameh Khamis e83c1672dd fix(models): tracked and emergency tints mix into aircraft paint instead of multiplying it
Aircraft models multiplied their tint into the shaded paint (HIGHLIGHT).
A saturated tint zeroes every channel it lacks: the tracked cyan (no red)
drew a red helicopter solid black, day or night, and a white Cessna one
flat cyan. Tinted models now mix the colour in at 30%
(AIRCRAFT_MODEL_TINT_MIX), so the paint stays readable and the colour
still marks them; untinted models still draw their own colours, and the
IR boost stays flat white.

Neither the multi-part models nor the part shader were involved: old and
new GLBs, with and without the shader, render the same pixels, and an
untinted model at night is lit by the default ambient term.

The new conformance check draw.models.paint draws a model painted with
COLOR_0 under a fixed sun and reads its colour by day, at night, and
under a tint mixed in. The parts test model can now carry vertex paint.
2026-11-17 16:50:52 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 3c3934582e Merge branch 'main' into fix/panel-speed-reported 2026-11-17 16:42:58 -08:00
Sameh Khamis d79494ac89 fix(flights): panels show the reported ground speed while a placement waits
A host-supplied placement's speed is how fast the marker is drawn. While it
waits for its fixes to catch up it stands still at 0, so tracked-aircraft
panels and the cockpit readout showed 0 m/s for an aircraft in flight.

displayedKinematics now takes derivedFromPlacement: when the drawn speed is a
placement's, the reported ground speed is shown, and the placement's only when
nothing is reported. The placement speed still drives motion and dead
reckoning. Civil and military tracked descriptors pass it from the new
_drSpeedPlaced scratch, which placeLiveAircraft sets.
2026-11-17 16:31:03 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 1f9d88ca1a Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/main' into models/three-km-true-size 2026-11-17 16:06:36 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 14aa85e638 fix(vessels): the layer turns on even when its feed fails
Turning vessels on returned what the first live poll answered, so a
failing feed (such as a missing AIS key) made enable() resolve false and
the layer reported it could not be turned on. loadLivePositions again
resolves with nothing once the poll is done; going back to live reads the
poll's answer through its own path.
2026-11-17 15:45:49 -08:00
Sameh Khamis b9cbc42f20 Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/main' into models/three-km-true-size
# Conflicts:
#	docs/CURRENT-STATE.md
2026-11-17 15:29:39 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 7186f720df Sprites for helicopters, ground vehicles, stations and vessel types; history to live without an empty map; model parts in Cesium
Aircraft icons are one size; helicopters turn a three-frame rotor while
airborne or moving; ADS-B ground vehicles share one amber sprite and
stations/obstacles one mast; vessels get hull sprites by type and one buoy.
Going live keeps contacts until the first live answer and replaces them by
id; fast playback holds before the loaded positions end and prefetches
ahead. Cesium models move their parts from the optional model part state.
2026-11-17 15:09:54 -08:00
German Khokhlov 301dee2174 Register TransLink Cairns through transitFeed and drop tests that restate data 2026-11-18 02:14:59 +04:00
German Khokhlov 02f0063cca Tighten the TransLink and Adelaide Metro docs, comments and release note 2026-11-18 02:11:42 +04:00
German Khokhlov d7b38c8c62 Merge branch 'main' into feat/australia-transit
# Conflicts:
#	docs/CURRENT-STATE.md
2026-11-18 02:10:07 +04:00
Sameh Khamis b041fea7a6 Deselecting a plane drawn as a model no longer flashes its icon
A selected plane is drawn by its own model, and its fleet model was let go once
that model drew. Deselecting showed the icon at once, and the icon stayed for
about a second while a new fleet model loaded.

The fleet model now stays loaded but hidden while the plane is selected, kept
where the plane is. Deselecting hands the plane back to it in the same frame,
and the icon shows only when there is no loaded fleet model. Military aircraft
share this code. Vessels never swap models on selection, so they had no flash.
2026-11-17 11:27:21 -08:00
Sameh Khamis 36624cd329 3D models only within 3 km of the camera, at true size
An aircraft, vessel, transit or rail vehicle now draws as its 3D model only
when it is within 3 km of the camera, and as its icon farther away. A model
already drawn is kept out to 3.6 km, so a vehicle on the edge does not flicker.
Proximity and All use the same distance and still differ by how many models
they allow (150 and 350). Models are drawn at their true size: the minimum
pixel size that inflated distant models is gone.

The camera altitude above which no model is considered is now the highest
aircraft the layers draw (30 km) plus the 3.6 km, so a camera high above the
ground still models an aircraft close to it. Cockpit's aircraft silhouettes
keep their own 150/185 km and 400/450 km bands, since they are icons.
2026-11-17 11:21:08 -08:00
Denis Groshev 1e2332eeb6 LIVE loads YouTube only after Play, and stops when its view is hidden
Selecting a station no longer builds the player: the LIVE section and the
Cockpit's LIVE page show a poster with Play under the line that YouTube sees
the viewer's IP address, as SECURITY.md asks of third-party media. The player
goes when the section collapses, Context collapses or closes, the Cockpit
leaves its LIVE page, or the Cockpit is entered or left, so nothing plays
unseen. A selection that moves straight on to another entry of the same
station (the Cockpit stepping between views) keeps the player instead of
rebuilding it. SECURITY.md also lists the ISS telemetry relay.
2026-11-17 16:25:04 +01:00
Denis Groshev 71d57481b7 Merge main (624c229b): STATION and LIVE sit in the Inspector tab after the entity card
Main split Context into Inspector and Properties tabs and renders the
Inspector only while Context is open; the two sections join it there, after
the entity card. Locales, same-as-english and package boundaries keep both
sides, deduplicated (the branch had added 54 duplicate module entries).
2026-11-17 16:18:26 +01:00
manjunath22466 54fd3d3bed fix(picking): settle which layers act on a click when it resolves
The flights and military layers treat the aircraft they already track as
a passive pick, but they start tracking during the click itself. A card
handler running later in the same click then saw the plane as passive and
acted too: a quake card opened its source while the plane started
tracking, and fire, CCTV and vessel cards could do the same.

The pick registry now records the acting owners of a click's exact hit and
touch contact when the dispatcher first resolves them, and the quake,
FIRMS, CCTV, vessel and Context checks read that record for the rest of
the click. Calls without a click keep the live lookup.
2026-11-17 15:51:14 +05:30
manjunath22466 830c980ca6 fix(touch): give each tap to the layer that acts on it
On a coarse pointer the dispatcher can name a contact near the tap instead
of the exact pick. Only flights, military, vessels, radio and Street Level
act on such a contact, so they now register as expanded pick owners, and a
quake card or label yields only to them. A FIRMS fire or CCTV camera reached
only as a nearby contact no longer swallows a quake card, a quake label or
a vessel's own card tap, and FIRMS and CCTV cards yield to a contact whose
layer does act on it.

Radio and Street Level also pick through their own windows. A station or
Street Level item found only there, not as the touch contact, yields to
another layer's card painted over it, and Street Level takes its own touch
contact beyond its narrower window.

Fire, CCTV and vessel cards now act over a passive owner's pick (a flight
trail, the directions route), as the quake card does. The Context panel
leaves a passive route, or a fire or camera reached only as a nearby
contact, to the card painted over it.
2026-11-17 13:18:32 +05:30
manjunath22466 4804097ca1 Merge origin/main into fix/earthquake-click-details 2026-11-17 11:49:17 +05:30
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju efffe3005c Fix the card previews' review findings
- A route globe that cannot draw tells the card, which shows another view.
- A card opened before the model set has loaded waits for that load.
- The model turns at the same rate on any display, and holds still under
  reduced motion.
- A hidden cockpit view stops drawing.
- The route plane keeps the craft's latest position through the fly-in.
- Metric altitude graphs keep main's 0.5% change threshold.

Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 15:57:40 -08:00
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju 3a0842c103 Draw the card previews through the renderer, and show vessel photos too
- The route globe, turning model and cockpit view are the renderer's: the
  Cesium plugin hands them over as its `cardPreviews` application hook
  (src/render/cesium/cardPreviews.js), and the card's tiles keep only the
  words, figures and HUD laid over them. Nothing in the UI reaches Cesium,
  and a renderer without the hook leaves the card its photo and figures.
- The turning model is the fleet model the globe draws for the aircraft's
  type, from the set loaded at startup, so opening a card fetches nothing.
  The flights layer's record now carries the type code and emitter category
  that pick it.
- The photo comes from the item's own layer: the flights layer's
  Planespotters photo for the plane it tracks, and the vessels layer's Open
  Vessel Photos photo for the vessel selected, with its credit. It no longer
  waits for Contacts to follow the same aircraft.
- The satellite models are left out: the card shows a satellite's ground
  view and graphs its altitude and speed.
- The route globe's airport codes are drawn into its own small scene, the
  compass reads its course in the active language, the callouts no longer
  speak to screen readers every six seconds, and figures use the app's
  number format. Esri's tile address and credit live in one place.

Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 15:44:35 -08:00
Manjunath PaparajuandSameh Khamis 1ce7e51c22 Bring Contacts, Space Missions and Radio back into Context
The Context panel's main tab shows the mode row again, with Contacts
(nearby sites search, the TR-3B toggle and the Awareness list) and Space
Missions (the roster and launch replay); only the Properties tab hides
them. Radio shows while its layer is on, and turning Radio or Launches on
opens Context. When Contacts follows the aircraft the card shows, its list
sits inside the card in a compact form and the card leaves out the flights
and vessels Contacts already lists. The card's Enter Cockpit replaces the
Contacts button, and leaving the cockpit returns focus to it.

Co-authored-by: Sameh Khamis <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 14:59:18 -08:00
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju 4b350cb9ae Translate the rest of the Context card's facts
Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 14:59:17 -08:00
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju 4554713f98 Translate the Context panel
Marks the Context panel's remaining strings and translates them into every locale.

Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 14:59:17 -08:00
Sameh KhamisandManjunath Paparaju 902689da8a Keep Context inside the package boundaries
The shell passes the ground picker to the click bridge, so the UI shell no
longer pulls in the annotation and search stack. Context's new modules are
owned by the packages that import them and formatted with the rest.

Co-authored-by: Manjunath Paparaju <[email protected]>
2026-11-16 14:59:01 -08:00
Manjunath Paparaju 0fe6fd2bb8 Show transit vehicle facts, motion and a fleet breakdown in Context
A transit vehicle picked on the map now finds its record in Context (the
click carries the feed and vehicle key), so the card shows its operator,
place, route, report age and the operator's last reported state in plain
words. The layer card breaks transit in view down by motion (moving,
stopped, waiting for an update, no recent fix), mode, operator, last
reported state and crowding where the feed has it; vehicle-position feeds
carry no timetable, so early or late is not shown. Rows in the in-view
list carry a motion icon.
2026-11-16 14:58:53 -08:00
Manjunath Paparaju 5c580cbd4a Update the flight record expectation for route preview fields 2026-11-16 14:58:53 -08:00
Manjunath Paparaju cc83763452 Rebuild the Context panel around the selected item and the view
Clicking anything a layer can identify opens one card in Context: a hero
tile (route globe and 3D model for a flight, the camera for CCTV, headline
figures otherwise), its facts, actions with Cockpit or the orbital view as
the primary one, and a standard set of nearby blocks (weather and local
time, flights, vessels, hazards, alerts) within one radius the user sets.
Aircraft show altitude as a graph. Things that move are followed when
picked, and a card closes when its layer is turned off.

With nothing selected the panel describes the view: the layers that are on
with a breakdown of what each holds, the camera's height, what is in view,
then time, weather and local news. From far out it shows worldwide counts
per layer. A search field in the header narrows whatever the panel shows.

Prototype. Context reads weather and hazard feeds while its panel is closed,
the two 3D previews on a flight card repaint continuously, Follow can show
pressed after tracking has ended elsewhere, and most new strings are fixed
English. Same-named sites are told apart by position, not by a stable id.
2026-11-16 14:58:53 -08:00