Starting the upstream timeout after the outbound queue let a request run
up to about 19 s, past the Directions layer's 15 s; the budget again runs
from arrival, queue wait included, and a budget spent before the request
leaves the queue answers 429 "routing busy" rather than an outage.
plan_route threw "Routing HTTP 502" for an outage, and voice passes only
the message on; it now throws "Routing service unavailable (HTTP 502)".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
When the OSRM routing service failed (a 5xx, a 403 block, a 404), answered
with a body that was not JSON, or did not answer at all (timeout, network
error), /api/route returned HTTP 200 with 'no route found' or 'route proxy
error'. plan_route turned that into invalid_arguments ("No walk route from
...: no route found"), blaming the caller for an outage, and the directions
layer reported "No route found between A and B".
The proxy now answers all of these with 502 {ok:false, error:'routing
service unavailable'}: a rejected upstream fetch, any failure status but
400, a non-JSON content type, and a body read that fails or does not parse.
An exception in the proxy's own code after that point is still a 200 'route
proxy error'. createRouteService throws for a 5xx before reading the body's
ok:false, so plan_route reports unavailable, and the directions source
treats any 5xx as "Routing unavailable (HTTP n)", also when the failure
page in front of the proxy is not JSON. OSRM's own refusal (a 400 such as
NoRoute, or a 200 without a route) still reads "no route found".
The 12 s upstream timeout now starts when the request leaves rather than
before it waits for an outbound slot, so a wait in the proxy's own queue
(up to about 8 s at the 1 s spacing) is not reported as an outage.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
RFC 9110 section 15.5.6 requires a 405 to name the methods it accepts, and
/api/radio/stations already does this in-tree. Thanks to kvnloo for catching it
on review. The same gap on the pre-existing handlers is tracked in #809 and is
deliberately left alone here.
/api/opensky, /api/adsblol/mil and /api/route answered any verb with the same
body while ignoring the request entirely. Measured against a running server
before the change: POST /api/opensky returned 200 with 833,759 bytes of live
state vectors, POST /api/adsblol/mil returned 47,372 bytes. Their siblings do
not: /api/geocode, /api/weather and /api/transit answer 405, and /api/overpass
is deliberately POST-only.
These three are read-only query proxies, so they now answer 405 to anything but
GET, using the wording and shape /api/geocode already uses. The refusal comes
first, before rate limiting and before any upstream call, which the tests
assert by stubbing fetch to throw.
Scope, stated plainly: this is a consistency and intent fix. No rate limiter
was being bypassed — /api/route already limits every request regardless of
verb, and the two aircraft routes have no limiter at all, only 9s and 12s
server-side caches that bound upstream cost for any method.
One existing fixture in src/search/geospatial.test.mjs built a request without
a method, which a real Node request always has; it now sets GET.
Verified on a running server after the change: GET still 200 on all three,
POST 405 on all three, /api/overpass and the other proxies unchanged.
Suite goes from 5090 to 5092 tests, 0 failures.
Supersedes #219 by @spcpza, ported onto the current component layout with fixes from review.
Verified before merge: format, package boundaries, unit suite, build, and the browser tracking suite; a browser harness for the change where one applies; adversarial review applied.
Co-authored-by: spcpza <[email protected]>